Anna Eva Fay
In the smoke filled parlours and theatres of 19th century America and Europe, where belief in the supernatural collided with entertainment.
Anna Eva Fay was a name that inspired fascination, reverence and sometimes fear. She was a true pioneer in the worlds of spiritualism and mentalism, her performances blurred the lines between the mystical and the theatrical. Her career set the stage for the development of modern mentalism.
Early life
Born Ann Eliza Heathman in Southington, Ohio, on 31st March 1851.
Anna grew up during a time when spiritualism was taking America by storm.
The 19th century saw the rise of the séance room, table rapping and spirit mediums. Many women found fame in these circles and Anna was one of the first to take these phenomena onto the stage as a public performance.
She adopted the stage name Anna Eva Fay and she began performing spiritualistic exhibitions by the age of 15.
Unlike many mediums who operated in private homes or spiritualist circles,
she ventured into the world of show business where she would draw immense crowds eager to witness indescribable phenomena.
The mind reading sensation
Her early performances included spirit manifestations and séances,
dark room spectacles where objects moved, messages appeared from beyond and ghostly forms emerged but it was her later embrace of ‘mental telepathy’ and stage mind reading that defined her most influential work.
In the 1870s, she introduced audiences to the ‘second sight’ act, where she and a confederate would demonstrate what appeared to be psychic communication across distances.
Anna would be blindfolded or isolated on stage while her partner collected written questions from the audience. She would then answer the questions with spooky precision.
The act astounded audiences and the two person code systems and telepathy routines would later become staples in 20th century mentalism.
Her performances remained ambiguous, she did not openly claim psychic powers, but she never denied them either. She always encouraged the public to draw their own conclusions. This careful ambiguity became a blueprint for later performers who walked the tightrope between illusion and belief.
International fame
Anna’s fame wasn’t limited to the United States. She toured Britain and continental Europe. She performed for royalty, aristocrats and scientific investigators. Her shows filled theatres in London where she was billed as ‘The indescribable phenomenon’.
This was during a time when women rarely held positions of power in public entertainment, let alone in male dominated areas like magic.
Anna carved a path with poise and intellect. She challenged sceptics, mystified believers and even impressed magicians with her skill.
She also managed her brand with sharp business acumen.
She understood how to control the narrative around her performances,
issuing public challenges and inviting scrutiny while guarding her methods. In doing so, she became both a celebrity and an enigma.
The investigations and the Houdini connection
Her career coincided with growing public interest in spiritualism
and increasing scepticism. As the century progressed, scientists, magicians and intellectuals began investigating psychic claims more seriously.
One of Anna’s notable interactions was with Harry Houdini, the famous escape artist and sceptic who later made it his mission to expose fraudulent mediums. Unlike many other spiritualists of that era, Anna maintained Houdini’s respect.
He openly admired her intelligence and theatrical mastery, noting in his writings that she was a performer of rare genius who never exploited belief in harmful ways.
Even magician and mentalist Joseph Dunninger, another famous debunker of fraudulent mediums, acknowledged her legacy, praising her as a pioneer who understood both the psychology and mystery required to create powerful performances.
Retirement and mentorship
After a long and celebrated career, Anna Eva Fay retired from active performance in the early 1900s but she remained a figure of great influence within the mentalism and magic communities.
She became a mentor and friend to several younger performers, including Theodore Annemann, who is often credited with laying the foundations
of modern mentalism in the 20th century. Annemann’s famous billet work and book tests owe a philosophical debt to Anna Eva Fay’s blend of mysticism, suggestion and theatrical flair.
Legacy
Anna Eva Fay’s name may not be as instantly recognisable as Houdini or Annemann but her contributions to mentalism is vast. Her legacy endured long after her final performance. Even after her death in 1927, Anna Eva Fay was spoken of as a legend, a teacher and a mystery still not fully solved.
She was among the first to:
Present psychic phenomena as theatrical performance.
Develop mental telepathy acts using coded communication
Establish a female presence in a predominantly male artform
Her act wasn’t about fooling the audience, it was about creating an experience of wonder, a theatrical illusion that invited the imagination to run wild and this philosophy is still alive in modern mentalism.
I don’t think it would be an exaggeration to call Anna Eva Fay
the mother of modern mentalism.
Her work predates the mentalism of Annemann, precedes the psychology of Derren Brown and laid the groundwork for an entire genre of entertainment that balances intuition, theatrics and subtle deception.
Her shows were more than exhibitions, they were rituals of belief, choreographed to trigger awe and introspection. For those exploring the roots of mentalism especially the role that women played in shaping it, Anna Eva Fay is a name that must be known, studied and celebrated.
Stay Weird
ЯYΛП MΣПƬIƧ
International Man of Mischief