A History of Mentalism
From oracles to mind readers and everything in between
The mentalist’s lineage
Before the stooges, peek wallets and TV talent shows. Before the term mentalist made its way onto glossy posters there was mystery.
Mentalism didn’t start with top hats and clipboards.
It started with whispers in temples, Omens in flames and priests who would divine souls.
Light a candle and dim your disbelief because we’re about to travel through the evolution of mentalism. From its ancient roots to its modern form.
Somewhere along the way I’ll probably offend a few sceptics.
Standard practice really!
The ancient mind games
Before it was called mentalism, it was divination.
The art of tapping into unseen forces to reveal hidden truths.
We’re not talking party tricks here.
Egyptian priests interpreted dreams and used star maps to forecast floods, famine and fates.
Greek oracles like those at Delphi, sat in smoke filled caves and delivered prophecies that kings would kill for.
In China, readers of the I Ching offered answers from the universe one coin toss at a time.
Were they mystics, frauds or performers?
The truth is they were early mentalists with killer atmospheres and they knew how to sell themselves.
The rise of the Seer
As centuries passed mentalism wore new masks, the medieval world saw a clash between mysticism and control.
Enter the wandering wise ones:
Gypsy fortune tellers reading palms at markets.
Astrologers charting fate from stars and moon signs.
Witch doctors and shamans using trance states to diagnose and divine.
They weren’t just guessing, they were observing everything
from eye flickers to nervous fidgets and even clothing choices.
They were human lie detectors long before polygraphs existed.
Today we call it cold reading, back then it was simply knowing things you shouldn’t. Add a sprinkle of performance, a dash of charisma and you’ve got a crowd hanging on your every word.
The age of Spiritualism
As we entered the 1800s, it was industrial revolution by day and spiritual revolution by night. The world was changing fast and so was death.
People missed their loved ones, they wanted contact and some kind of closure.
Enter the Spiritualist movement
The Fox sisters heard knocks from the great beyond or maybe it was somebody in the attic?
Mediums held séances in darkened parlours, channelling spirits, revealing names and moving furniture without touching it.
Slate writing, table tipping and spirit trumpets became all the rage.
But it is widely believed that many of these techniques were tricks, brilliant psychological tricks.
The mentalists of today owe a debt to those ghostly performers.
Mentalism and spiritualism share a blurry border and it’s one that still sparks debate. Is it okay to suggest something supernatural on stage?
Or should we reveal it’s all a trick?
From spirit to stage
By the late 19th and early 20th centuries, the world was splitting in two:
The spiritualists doubled down on ghosts.
The scientific showmen doubled down on psychology.
Cue: The Great Alexander or you may know him as:
Alexander the Man Who Knows.
He was a stage performer who claimed to read minds and predict fates.
He wore a turban and took himself very seriously.
Alexander was one of the first to brand himself as a mentalist.
Others soon followed. These weren’t wizards, they were mental manipulators. They didn’t float tables, they floated ideas.
Mentalism’s modern renaissance
Fast forward to the late 20th and early 21st centuries.
Magic was changing again, the internet brought exposure.
Audiences got cynical and yet mentalism began to rise.
Audiences were craving mystery that felt real.
Banachek mastered psychological subtleties and advised on TV shows while openly debunking supernatural claims.
Derren Brown blurred the line between suggestion, psychology and impossible predictions. He called himself a trickster, yet people still wondered if he was psychic.
Luke Jermay, Colin Cloud, Marc Paul, and many others fused technique with theatre, creating mentalism with a personal touch.
Mentalism became more than effects, it became about experiences and narratives with emotion and feelings.
With that came a certain tension:
Should mentalists reveal it’s a trick or let the mystery linger?
For more on this subject check out:
The digital mind meld
Now we arrive at a strange new frontier:
The internet and Ai driven magic.
Mentalists are creating effects over Zoom.
TikTok mind readers perform 15 second miracles.
Apps replace billets.
Modern creators like Fraser Parker, Peter Turner and Christopher Parrish explore propless mentalism where effects happen in the participant’s mind alone. No props or resets, just language and suggestion. It’s a minimalist’s dream and it proves that mentalism evolves with the times.
The eternal debate
Throughout mentalism’s history, one question constantly echoes like a spirit knock on the séance table:
Are you really psychic?
Some say yes, some say no, some grin and never answer.
Mentalism has always danced on the line between entertainment and belief.
That’s what makes it powerful, the ancient oracles knew it.
The spiritualists knew it and deep down, so do you.
Whether you frame your act as psychological insight, mystical ritual or full blown mediumship, what really matters is this:
Are you leaving your audience changed?
Mentalism isn’t about answers, it’s about possibility.
Why this history matters
You’re not just learning methods and scripting lines, you’re inheriting a lineage. Mentalism is more than just a category in a magic shop.
It’s a living, evolving tradition that has worn the robes of priesthood, the flair of theatre and the sharpness of science.
Understanding where it came from gives you knowledge and it’s up to you if choose to honour it, bend it or break it.
Want to create your own style? Study those who broke the rules.
Want to be more impactful? Study the moments mentalism changed lives.
Want to be unforgettable? Stop performing and start transforming.
Fragmented Thoughts
If you made it this far congratulations, your brain survived.
I’ve had 2 Leftfield albums, 1 Dreadzone album and a few prodigy tracks to keep me company while writing this.
But you did it all without music, well done!
Mentalism is ancient and modern, sceptical and sacred, funny and frightening. It doesn’t live in any one box, it climbs out of them.
Call To Action A.K.A. The Magical Shove
If you’re as obsessed with this art as I am, then why don’t you email me to contribute an article, a tip, a trick or even a strange historical tidbit about mentalism. Let’s turn this blog into a living museum of minds.
Got an idea for the upcoming Tutorials page?
I’m currently building it brick by digital brick, come and be a part of the foundation.
Just want to share your thoughts?
Tell me what you love, hate or secretly desire. I’m all ears!
Reach out and get involved.
Let’s make mentalistblogger.com the weirdest corner of the web.
Think weird… Read minds…
Never reveal your socks… Or was it secrets?
ЯYΛП MΣПƬIƧ
International Man of Mischief